Only a full statutory inquiry at Yorkshire CCC can get to truth - Yorkshire Post Letters

From: Robin Smith, Shadwell, Leeds.

Your editorial, November 4, asserted that the disciplinary proceedings against Yorkshire CCC “are rightly being held in public”.

You failed to remind readers that your cricket correspondent called for a statutory public enquiry into Mr Rafiq’s allegations many months ago.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

He was right to do so, and the YP deserves credit for endorsing the need for transparency at that comparatively early stage.

A general view of Yorkshire County Cricket Club's Headingley Stadium in Leeds in 2021. PIC: Peter Powell/PA WireA general view of Yorkshire County Cricket Club's Headingley Stadium in Leeds in 2021. PIC: Peter Powell/PA Wire
A general view of Yorkshire County Cricket Club's Headingley Stadium in Leeds in 2021. PIC: Peter Powell/PA Wire

The problem with the current disciplinary process being conducted in public is that witnesses will not be afforded the protection of privilege which Mr Rafiq enjoyed when making his unchallenged allegations at a DCMS hearing.

Witnesses will be naturally reluctant to expose themselves to claims and there is a real danger that the current process will collapse as a result.

The answer is a full statutory inquiry with a remit to examine all the available evidence and to be chaired by an independent senior lawyer. Only such an inquiry can get to the truth.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

That is what those at the Club have wanted from the outset, and the Yorkshire Post was right to champion the cause of truth all those months ago. You are right now to continue your pursuit of the cause of truth and it is to be hoped that the ECB takes due notice.